Could this be where the next pandemic starts? Could this be precisely the point where the next pandemic breaks out? Certainly, it is a possibility, especially when the chain of events that could cause an epidemic far more severe than COVID-19 resembles the opening scenario of a disaster movie. A truly bad disaster movie, in which the level of carelessness and irresponsibility is unbelievable.

A report published by the investigative organization ProPublica reveals that bird flu has been spreading since August on a mink farm in Utah, USA, while public authorities have apparently done almost nothing.

AD PLACEHOLDER

In 2023, in an article for The Guardian, I warned that mink farms could hardly have been better designed to create conditions for deadly pandemics to break out. For three reasons: minks are fed waste from chickens, cows and other farm animals, where new variants of viruses often develop; minks can easily be infected by both bird flu and human flu viruses, which can then exchange genetic material, turning a bird disease into one that can affect humans; and minks have an exceptionally high zoonotic potential—that is, the ability to infect animals of other species, including humans.

I pointed out that bird flu viruses that pass to humans can be extremely dangerous: of the people known to have been infected with the H5N1 variant since 1997, 48 percent have died.

The first death from bird flu in the US this year has just been confirmed. The victim was infected by a herd of dairy cows affected by the virus. Although this virus is causing devastating damage to populations of wild birds and some mammals, fortunately, its transmissibility from one person to another has so far been very low.

If this ideal environment for viruses to mix, such as mink farms, were to produce a variant that is both highly lethal and more easily transmissible, you would be well advised to start preparing your will. For this reason, and also because of the needless cruelty of the fur industry, I have called for a global treaty to ban mink farming.

I did not expect governments to take immediate action, however compelling the case. However, I also did not expect them to behave as though their aim were to help spread a deadly virus. That is how officials in the US appear to have acted.

ProPublica found that, instead of trying to contain the virus by shutting down the farm and culling the minks, Utah state departments tried to keep the case secret. Public health officials did not test farm workers for symptoms or trace their contacts, despite the fact that they are in daily contact with infected minks and are often bitten or scratched by them.

Why? Because of complaints from the state agriculture department that “the farmers were annoyed” by the testing.

Utah’s state veterinarian, Amanda Price, said the outbreak was “devastating.” But she was not talking about public health. She was talking about the impact on the farmer.

“This is his life’s work, and he is watching it be destroyed. I really hope you understand the human side of this situation,” she said.

Yes, we understand: eight billion people could be at risk if nothing is done. Culling the minks could destroy the farmer’s business, and he should be compensated for it. But not culling them could have far more serious consequences. Could there be a clearer case of putting special interests ahead of the public interest?

She also stated:

“There aren’t many other options besides sitting back, waiting and seeing what happens… If we start seeing people actively dying from this, then, of course, we would change the way we respond.”

By then, it may be too late.

The main effort seems to have been to protect the farm’s interests. The state has not declared an emergency, because officials reason that this could “alarm animal rights organizations.” But such an action could also alarm public health organizations, or anyone concerned about human life.

We have now entered flu season. The longer this situation continues, the greater the chance that a much more easily transmissible variant of the virus will develop on the mink farm.

These officials make the scientists in the first episode of the series Pluribus look like responsible citizens. The officials in this case are not following signals sent by extraterrestrials. On the contrary, they seem to be following signals sent by commercial interests.

If there is one thing we have learned from the influence of the tobacco and sugar industries, it is that corporate lobbyists should have no role whatsoever in public health decision-making. Yet they are involved in every form of decision-making. Whichever issue ultimately delivers the fatal blow, this could be what drives us to destruction.

Although mink farms pose a particular risk, all forms of industrial livestock farming pose a high risk of creating and spreading pandemics. In fact, it is the combination of mink farms with chicken, pig and dairy farms that creates such enormous potential for catastrophe.

The meat industries can be considered disease amplifiers, as they create the conditions in which a virus with low pathogenicity can easily become a more pathogenic variant. Feed minks the internal organs of animals so that this virus can mix with human flu viruses, and then everything can take on catastrophic proportions.

In this respect, too, the level of negligence appears frightening. US Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has argued that chicken farmers “should perhaps consider allowing bird flu to spread throughout the flock, in order to identify and preserve birds that are immune to it.”

The US Agriculture Secretary has expressed support for this idea. Such an approach would not only be extremely dangerous, but also pointless, since the genetic diversity of chickens has been reduced to the absolute minimum in order to produce near-identical birds.

This resembles the “let the virus spread” positions taken by the administrations of Donald Trump and Boris Johnson during the first wave of COVID-19.

Kennedy has also claimed that the H5N1 variant “doesn’t seem to harm wild birds—they have a kind of immunity.” This is completely untrue.

Although we are now more aware than before of the impact of the tobacco, sugar, alcohol, junk food, gambling and fossil fuel industries, most people still do not understand the scale of the risk posed by the livestock industry.

It is not only one of the leading causes of greenhouse gas emissions, habitat destruction, the decline and extinction of wild animals, and pollution of rivers and seas. It is also the biggest risk factor in the emergence of new pandemics, both directly and through the conversion of ecosystems into agricultural land.

It may also be the leading cause of the spread of antimicrobial resistance.

All these consequences come from the industry that supplies us with meat, eggs and milk.

We have often been warned that the things we should fear most are those we do not think about. It is time we started thinking about this.

George Monbiot is a columnist for The Guardian.