Imer Mushkolaj

AD PLACEHOLDER

The violence in Skenderaj, where the mayor, together with people close to him, is suspected of having been involved in beating the chairman of the Vetëvendosje Movement there, who is also a deputy minister, is one of those events that must not be downplayed, justified, or dismissed as an ordinary incident. This case is not merely about a brawl between individuals, but about a dangerous political message: that those in power can use physical force against their opponents. This is alarming.

Kosovo has gone through a great deal to build a democratic system in which political competition is conducted with words, ideas, and votes. Not with fists. Not through intimidation. Not by physically lynching those who think differently. The moment violence enters as an instrument of political communication, democracy begins to slide onto dangerous ground, where the physically stronger seek to replace argument.

Public officials and those who hold local power have a much greater responsibility than ordinary citizens. They should set an example of restraint, not promote aggression. Because when a mayor engages in physical violence against a political opponent, he does not merely debase himself. He degrades the institution he represents.

But more troubling than the event itself is the silence that followed. In countries with even a minimally democratic culture, the party’s response should have been immediate and clear: condemn the violence, distance itself from the officials’ conduct, and demand accountability. Yet in the case of Skenderaj, what many senior officials of the Democratic Party of Kosovo displayed was a cold, almost routine silence, as if the event merited neither concern nor reflection. This silence makes the problem even greater. Violence is normalized not only by those who commit it, but also by those who do not condemn it. By those who turn a blind eye because the perpetrator is “one of ours.” By those who speak out only when the victim belongs to their own political camp. And it is precisely this double standard that has poisoned public discourse in Kosovo for many years.

If the beating of a political opponent is justified today because “they provoked us,” tomorrow every other form of aggression will be justified. That is how a society’s degradation begins. Not all at once, but gradually, by making violence a normal part of public life.

Election campaigns in Kosovo have long been toxic. Hate speech, name-calling, slander, and the demonization of opponents have become routine. Political opponents are no longer seen as democratic rivals, but as enemies to be humiliated, eliminated, or destroyed. And when politics continuously produces this climate, physical violence becomes just the next step. Therefore, the case in Skenderaj should not be viewed as an isolated incident. It is a direct consequence of the political culture that has been built over the years. A culture in which leaders inflame militancy, then pretend to be surprised when that militancy erupts into aggression.

*  *  *

Politicians in Kosovo constantly talk about democracy, but many of them cannot tolerate the existence of differing opinions. They regard the municipality, the party, or the city as private property, places where opponents have no right to enter. This mindset is deeply undemocratic.

No one should be afraid to hold a political event in any city in Kosovo. No one should feel physically endangered because of their political beliefs. The moment citizens begin to think that political participation could expose them to violence, democracy begins to lose its meaning.

It is especially problematic when violence comes from people who hold public office. They have not only legal, but also moral responsibilities. A mayor is not a neighborhood partisan, but represents an institution. Every action of his sends a message to citizens. And when that message is that opponents can be physically attacked, the harm goes far beyond a momentary incident.

Another important element was missing from this whole story: reflection. There has still been no sincere remorse; on the contrary, there has been downplaying, justifications, and attempts to shift the focus. This shows that our politics has still not understood that violence is not merely a criminal problem. It is a cultural and political problem.

Democratic societies are measured not only by the elections they hold, but by how they treat political opponents. Democracy is not tested when we agree with one another, but when we face someone we cannot stand politically and nevertheless recognize their right to speak, organize, and compete freely.

Kosovo urgently needs a change in its political culture. Less partisan hysteria and more public responsibility. Fewer militants who see politics as physical warfare, and more citizens who understand that an opponent is not an enemy.

This responsibility rests with political parties, leaders, and every public official. They must make it clear that violence is unacceptable. Whether it comes from an opponent or from their own people. Because if violence is tolerated today for partisan gain, tomorrow no one will be able to control it.

Politics should be a contest of ideas, not a contest of strength. Words should defeat fists, not the other way around.