Author: Gjon Culaj, associate at the “OCTOPUS” Institute
The current security environment is undergoing profound changes, with traditional forms of conflict increasingly being replaced by sophisticated and difficult-to-identify forms of hostile action.
In this new reality, hybrid threats have become one of the main challenges for democratic states, as they combine military and civilian instruments, conventional and unconventional methods, as well as political, economic, informational and cyber tools, with the aim of weakening state institutions, undermining democratic processes and eroding citizens’ trust in the political system.
NATO defines hybrid threats as a combination of military and non-military means, overt and covert, including disinformation, cyberattacks, economic pressure and political interference, intended to destabilize democratic societies (NATO, 2026).
This concept was developed to explain new forms of conflict that are not limited to the use of armed force. According to Frank G. Hoffman (2007), “Hybrid wars encompass a wide range of ways of waging war, such as conventional capabilities, irregular tactics and formations, terrorist acts and various forms of coercion, as well as criminal activity” (Hoffman, 2007:8). Meanwhile, in his book “Mastering the Gray Zone: Understanding a Changing Era of Conflict,” Michael J. Mazarr highlights one of the most distinctive features of hybrid threats, the so-called “gray zone,” a strategic space between peace and open conflict, where the traditional boundaries between these two states become blurred. In this environment, state and non-state actors use a combination of political, economic, informational, cyber and military tools to advance their interests without crossing the threshold that would trigger a direct military response. Although these actions often unfold gradually and are difficult to identify as direct aggression, their effects can be profound, weakening state institutions, undermining citizens’ trust in public authorities and threatening the stability of the democratic order (Mazarr, 2015:55-56).
Hybrid threats as a challenge to democracy
Modern democracies present attractive targets for hybrid threats because of their political openness, media pluralism and freedom of expression. According to Tanja Ellingsen (2024), hybrid actors seek to exploit precisely these democratic characteristics to fuel political polarization, distrust of institutions and the weakening of democratic processes (Ellingsen, 2024:46).
According to Chodak, Krassowski and Wierzchowski (2021), hybrid threats rely mainly on non-military instruments and psychological influence on society.
The authors emphasize that the civilian population is both a source of societal vulnerabilities and a direct target of disinformation and information-manipulation campaigns.
In this sense, civil society is not merely the object of hybrid actions, but also becomes the main arena where competition for influence, trust and public perception takes place (Chodak et al., 2021:92–93).
Another equally important element of hybrid threats is information warfare and disinformation. State and non-state actors use social media and digital platforms to spread false narratives, influence public opinion and create political polarization.
According to Rühle and Roberts (2021), these campaigns aim to undermine citizens’ trust in democratic institutions and create “alternative realities” in which truth and propaganda become difficult to distinguish. As a result, democratic processes such as elections and public debate become more vulnerable to manipulation.
Another dimension worth mentioning is the vulnerability of democratic institutions to cyberattacks. Critical state infrastructure, electoral systems and communication networks can be direct targets of hybrid attacks. These attacks aim not only to cause technical damage, but also to create uncertainty and distrust in the state’s ability to ensure normal functioning. According to NATO’s concept of cybersecurity, resilience to such attacks requires not only technical protection, but also the capacity for rapid institutional and societal recovery (NATO, 2024).
Hybrid threats also contribute to social polarization and the weakening of democratic cohesion. By exploiting existing political, ethnic or social divisions, external actors can deepen internal conflicts and weaken democratic consensus. According to Ellingsen (2024), the main aim of these interventions is not always regime change, but the creation of an unstable environment in which institutions lose legitimacy and citizens lose trust in the democratic system (Ellingsen, 2024:45).
In this context, strengthening democratic resilience is a pillar of the defense of contemporary political systems. Resilience is the ability of a political and social system to anticipate, withstand and recover from hybrid shocks, while maintaining its core functions and institutional stability. This capacity involves not only responding to crises, but also adapting and functioning democratically under conditions of external and internal pressure (NATO, 2025). According to NATO’s concept of resilience, strengthening the resilience of democratic societies involves a comprehensive institutional approach, the development of cybersecurity, the promotion of transparency in governance and the empowerment of citizens through media literacy, with the aim of increasing society’s ability to withstand hybrid threats and disinformation (NATO, 2024).
A well-informed society, with stable, transparent and functional institutions, is one of the most decisive factors in confronting these threats. A high level of public awareness and media literacy makes it more difficult to manipulate perceptions and spread disinformation, while resilient institutions increase the state’s ability to prevent and withstand various forms of hybrid pressure.
Resilience as a strategic concept for Kosovo’s defense against hybrid threats
In contemporary security literature, resilience is defined as a system’s ability to absorb shocks, adapt and recover from crises while preserving its fundamental functions.
In the context of hybrid threats, this means that the state does not focus solely on preventing attacks, but on building capabilities that make society more resistant to manipulation, destabilization and external interference.
According to the modern concept of security, resilience has shifted from a reactive approach to a proactive strategic one. Michael Hartmann (2017) argues that hybrid threats target not only physical infrastructure, but also political decision-making processes and institutional trust, making resilience an indispensable instrument of national security and defense (Hartmann, 2017:4).
In this sense, Kosovo should adopt resilience not as an additional component of security, but as the central architecture of state defense. For Kosovo, building strategic resilience can be structured around several key pillars that interact with one another and create an integrated system of defense against hybrid threats.
The institutional pillar is the foundation of strategic resilience. Strong, transparent and functional institutions are a prerequisite for political stability and resistance to external interference. According to Kalniete, S., & Pildegovičs, T. (2021), institutional fragility significantly increases exposure to the influence of hybrid actors in political processes, thereby contributing to a gradual decline in public trust in democratic institutions (Kalniete & Pildegovičs, 2021). Trustworthy institutions are the strongest mechanism against disinformation and manipulation, because citizens have a reliable point of reference for distinguishing accurate information from manipulation.
In the digital age, cyberspace has become a key arena of hybrid conflict.
Cyberattacks on state systems aim not only to cause technical damage, but also to create institutional uncertainty and public distrust (NATO, 2024). In Kosovo’s case, defense against hybrid threats should not be understood solely as strengthening military or police capabilities, but as creating a resilient state and society, ready to withstand destabilizing operations. The very nature of hybrid threats is to exploit the state’s internal weaknesses, operating in the political, informational, economic, social and cyber domains. For this reason, resilience must be placed at the center of Kosovo’s national security concept.
In the context of Kosovo’s security, one of the main sources of hybrid threats is linked to political, informational, cyber and diplomatic activities originating from Serbia as a state actor in the region. These challenges do not take the form of an open military conflict, but rather emerge through a combination of unconventional means intended to affect Kosovo’s institutional stability, how it is perceived on the international stage, and internal social cohesion (KCSS, 2025:2).
Kosovo needs a conceptual transformation of its approach to security.
Instead of a model based primarily on responding to threats, it should build a model based on national resilience, in which the state, society and international partners function as parts of an integrated defense system. Only such a comprehensive approach can make Kosovo more resilient to hybrid threats and better able to maintain stability, security and democratic functioning in an increasingly complex strategic environment.
In the face of these challenges, Kosovo’s Security Strategy should adopt a more advanced approach to national resilience. This means that threats arising from disinformation, political influence, cyber operations and the instrumentalization of ethnic tensions by Serbia must be treated as part of national security on the same level as traditional threats.
For this reason, a future review of Kosovo’s Security Strategy should place democratic resilience at the center of the national security architecture. Alongside strengthening security and defense capabilities, specialized mechanisms should be developed for monitoring disinformation, protecting critical infrastructure, interinstitutional coordination and citizens’ media literacy. Only through such a comprehensive approach can and should Kosovo increase its ability to confront hybrid threats and protect the democratic functioning of the state.