Sir Geoffrey Nice: The Special Court Reflects Hidden Political Objectives
Sir Geoffrey Nice, one of Britain’s most renowned lawyers, who also served as a prosecutor at the Hague war crimes tribunal for Serbian dictator Slobodan Milošević, visited Pristina in recent days, where he took part in the “Bridges of Memory” conference, organized by KIPRED and the “Freedom Has a Name” organization. In an article published in […]
Sir Geoffrey Nice, one of Britain’s most renowned lawyers, who also served as a prosecutor at the Hague war crimes tribunal for Serbian dictator Slobodan Milošević, visited Pristina in recent days, where he took part in the “Bridges of Memory” conference, organized by KIPRED and the “Freedom Has a Name” organization.
In an article published in the conference’s online booklet, Sir Geoffrey shares his memories of the court, recalling a dispute with lawyers in which the British attorney says that the Specialist Chambers were created entirely as a result of sustained pressure from the EU and the US.
According to Nice: “In a later intervention concerning the Kosovo Specialist Chambers (KSC), I corrected a speaker who had claimed that this court had been established as the result of a sovereign decision by the Kosovo Assembly. I reminded those present that Kosovo’s elected representatives were, in reality, forced to accept this court under constant pressure from the European Union and the United States.”
The Briton, who also served for a time as an adviser to the Government of Kosovo during the process of establishing the Specialist Chambers, provides evidence of the EU’s unilateral actions in drafting the initial statute: “As part of Kosovo’s negotiating team, I was a direct witness that the Statute of the Specialist Chambers was not, in any meaningful sense, the result of an agreement with Kosovo. As soon as the European negotiators faced substantial objections to the draft statute from the Kosovo side, discussions practically came to a halt. What followed, in my experience, was the political imposition of a pre-drafted statute, shaped exclusively by EU and US actors.”
Nice assesses that “Kosovo had no real voice in its adoption, yet it was Kosovo that paid the price for these imposed actions, without any assurance that the proceedings would ultimately deliver justice or create a basis for reconciliation.”
Furthermore, Nice expresses concern that the court has hidden political objectives: “I have previously warned publicly that the way this court was created, beginning with the Marty Report and continuing thereafter, appeared to reflect hidden political objectives.”
According to Nice, “it has been difficult to determine these objectives precisely, but Serbia clearly seemed to be the state most likely to benefit from a court imposed in the way the Specialist Chambers were imposed, focused exclusively on one ethnicity for the 1998–1999 war.”
Referring to Thaçi’s trial, the lawyer, who now also holds the prestigious title of “Sir,” bestowed by Queen Elizabeth, agrees with the view that the Prosecutor’s indictment against Thaçi and others reflects a narrative focused on Serbia’s interests.
Nice elaborates on the arguments he has heard and the comparisons between the earlier Hague Tribunal and the Specialist Chambers.
“I had no reason to follow the charges brought in the case against Thaçi and others, and I did not do so. At the conference, I heard arguments that the Prosecutor’s indictment against Thaçi and others reflects a Serbia-centered narrative, and that the characterization of the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) as an organized military structure engaged in a Joint Criminal Enterprise is not supported by the earlier judgments of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY). Nothing in my recollection of the evidence presented during Milošević’s trial, or of subsequent developments, suggests to me that these arguments are inaccurate,” Sir Geoffrey Nice said.















