A Battle That Must Be Won
The most serious response to a court judgment is a strong legal counterargument. But that does not mean politics should remain silent. On the contrary, Kosovo’s institutions have a responsibility to speak clearly about the history of the war, the sacrifice of its citizens and the country’s right to defend its historical truth.
Imer Mushkolaj
The judgment of the Specialist Chambers in The Hague has changed an important chapter in the proceedings against the leaders of the Kosovo Liberation Army. The conviction of the four KLA leaders cannot be treated as the sole and definitive truth about the history of the Kosovo war, but neither can it be dismissed because of the political weight of the names of those convicted. The court has issued a first-instance decision. A new phase now begins: the appeal. This is precisely when Kosovo needs more seriousness and less noise.
The case against the four KLA leaders is not just a matter concerning four individuals, but part of a much broader debate about how the Kosovo war is treated, individual responsibility, the chain of command, evidence, testimony, legal standards and the interpretation of the circumstances in which the war took place. For this reason, every next step must be considered down to the last detail.
The defense must now be clear about what it is challenging, which points in the judgment can be legally contested and which arguments may carry weight before the Appeals Panel. Political statements are not enough, nor is repeating that the KLA fought a war of liberation. This is a historical and political truth for Kosovo’s society, but in the courtroom, what matters are the evidence, legal standards, interpretation of the law and how the first-instance conclusions were reached. Therefore, preparations for the appeal must be exceptional.
If Kosovo wishes to contribute seriously, it must do what is possible politically, institutionally and legally. Politics can create the space, resources and institutional support needed by the defense teams, while the lawyers must do the work that falls to them. This also requires a different kind of unity on the political scene. Not unity around a party or a leader, but a minimum consensus on certain interests connected to the state and its recent history.
Faced with proceedings that have lasted for years, Kosovo cannot continue to behave as though every issue related to the KLA should be used for internal clashes. It is not necessary for all parties to hold the same position on governance, the economy, dialogue with Serbia or social policies. Democracy thrives precisely on differences. But on such sensitive issues, there must be at least a minimum of institutional and political coordination. This is especially important now that the first-instance decision has been issued and the appeal process must be pursued to the fullest extent legally possible.
* * *
The best experts must be brought together. Every page of the judgment must be analyzed. Any inconsistencies between the evidence and the conclusions must be identified. The standards applied by the Trial Panel and the way the testimony was assessed must be examined. It must be clearly understood what can and cannot be requested on appeal. And above all, the temptation to replace legal arguments with emotional ones must be avoided. The most serious response to a court judgment is a strong legal counterargument. But that does not mean politics should remain silent.
On the contrary, Kosovo’s institutions have a responsibility to speak clearly about the history of the war, the sacrifice of its citizens and Kosovo’s right to defend its historical truth. They can do so through diplomacy, documentation, scholarly research, archives, testimony and serious international communication. What must be avoided is improvisation.
Kosovo has paid dearly for a lack of coordination. It has paid through political clashes, contradictory statements and the use of issues related to the war as weapons in everyday party battles. In the case of the Specialist Chambers, such conduct helps no one.
Now is not the time to ask which party might benefit politically from this process, but to ask what can be done to make the appeal process as strong and professional as possible.
If there is a moment when Kosovo’s political scene must demonstrate maturity, this is one of them.
The most useful unity would be around a simple principle: the legal defense must be as professional as possible, the institutions must be coordinated, and Kosovo’s history must be documented and defended with facts.
The first-instance judgment is not the end of the road. It is a new starting point. The appeal will be a test for the defense, but also a test of Kosovo’s seriousness. If we want our arguments to be heard, we must prepare them in the language justice understands: with evidence, law, facts and arguments. For the rest, politics can do what is required of it.
It must be united where necessary and avoid turning this process, too, into another internal political battle. The next battle can be won only with strong arguments.















